This was the latest selection for the book club to which I belong. It’s a novel written by a Native American author that explores what it is like to be a Native American living in an urban environment. The book is set in Oakland, and follows the paths of multiple characters leading up to a big pow wow.
For me, the strength of this book is in the way Orange uses different voices and narrative styles for each of the characters’ stories. He does manage to give each one a unique voice, which is tough to pull off well, especially with the number of threads and stories that are woven together into the larger tale.
The structure of this book reminds me of a Quentin Tarantino film. There are all these story lines that wind together, bringing the characters together in unexpected ways. Maybe a better analogy would be that the story resembles a Native American dream catcher, with all the stories knotted together; and yet somehow the nightmare is not caught, but slips through, a symbol of how the American Dream just doesn’t exist for so many people of indigenous cultures.
While the title of the book seems conciliatory, it is actually a reference to a Gertrude Stein quote, about how the lives and places we knew from our pasts are no longer there.
“Do you know what Gertrude Stein said about Oakland?” Rob says.
Dene shakes his head no but actually he knows, actually googled quotes about Oakland when researching for his project. He knows exactly what the guy is about to say.
“There is no there there,” he says in a kind of a whisper, with this goofy openmouthed smile Dene wants to punch. Dene wants to tell him he’d looked up the quote in its original context, in her Everybody’s Autobiography, and found that she was talking about how the place where she’d grown up in Oakland had changed so much, that so much development had happened there, that the there of her childhood, the there there, was gone, there was no there there anymore.
(pp. 38 – 39)
I think of the various times and places of my past, and those are just snapshots in time. They no longer exist. On a recent trip back to a city where I had lived for over 20 years, it was almost unrecognizable from what I remembered. There were shadows of what once was, almost like a distant echo that sparks a nostalgic memory, but the place itself is gone, changed beyond recognition. I can only imagine that this feeling must be magnified 100 fold for Native Americans, who were displaced and stripped of their homes.
The book is unsettling, and might be disturbing for some readers. But it is worth reading. We should not avoid reading about topics because they make us uncomfortable.
5 responses to “Thoughts on “There There” by Tommy Orange”
Nice review. I read this a few months ago. A difficult book to characterize. I like the dreamcatcher analogy. It was a moving and
And brutal read but worth our while in helping to understand the urban Indian experience. (Sorry, comment above sent too soon by mistake. )
Thanks for your comment, Deborah. Totally agree: brutal but important. Hope you are well. Cheers!
I’m glad to see your review, Jeff. I have seen this book on display at the library, but I didn’t know what it was about. I think it’s important to read books about uncomfortable things. Hope you had a good book club discussion!
Good morning, Barb. Hope you are well. Yeah, book was interesting, but not great. Writing was very good, stylistically. We have not had our discussion yet. Two weeks (i finished early). Cheers